She that is giddy (charliesmum) wrote in johnkerry04,
She that is giddy
charliesmum
johnkerry04

Regarding the 'not one damn dime day' thing

Since someone posted the information for this protest thing, I thought I'd post this link to Snopes.com that gives a nice analysis of this form of protesting.

the suggested scheme is one of the least effective forms of symbolic protest one could devise: it literally proposes that people do nothing, and doing nothing generates little, if any, publicity or news coverage. Massing thousands of people in one place and engaging speakers to make rousing public speeches provide vivid, well-defined images for the news media to pick up on, but pictures of people not spending money just don't make compelling fodder for newspapers and television. (Images of normally bustling malls, restaurants, and airports standing eerily devoid of human traffic might make for a good news story, but public opinion on this issue is far too divided for this protest to be able to bring all business to a grinding halt.)

I just thought it was interesting.
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 4 comments
I completely agree with this paragraph. Buy-nothing-day-protests are worthless.
you could atleast give it a shot. what harm could it do you to save money for one day?
what harm could it do you to save money for one day?

No harm, but the point is it won't attract any real notice, which is the point of protests. It would be more effective to march on Washington the day of the inaguration, for example, because that would be crowded and noisy and would attract media attention . Simply not going to the stores won't make anyone sit up and notice, unless somehow every single person in the country did it. And, since apparently 51% of the people wanted Bush in office, that is not going to happen. Snopes.com has a good article about it and explains it better than I can.

Agreed. Very few people will comply and it won't make news.